Review 023 · LED & Smart Bulbs

Smart Color Bulbs, Red Bulbs and a Motion Sensor Bulb Compared

A smart RGB bulb, a plain red bulb and a motion sensor bulb all screw into the same socket, but each one has a catch worth knowing first.

  • Published November 16, 2026
  • 13 min read
  • 3 products
  • TJOY · GREENIC

At a glance

Three bulbs for three small jobs

You carry groceries in from the garage and the hallway is dark. Or the Halloween party is two days out, and the porch still glows the same warm white it does every other night. Colored and motion-sensing bulbs fix those two small problems, and they screw into the sockets you already have.

Three bulbs are up for comparison, all in the standard A19 shape with an E26 screw base. The TJOY is a Wi-Fi and Bluetooth RGB bulb that you run from an app. The GREENIC red bulb is a plain colored LED with no app.

The second GREENIC has a motion and dusk sensor built into its top and gives off 5000K daylight white.

On paper they look alike. Each brand gives 9 watts and a 60 watt equivalent, and the TJOY and the motion bulb are both rated at 800 lumens. In use they behave differently, and each one has a catch that decides whether it fits your fixture.

The smart bulb needs 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi and its own app. The red bulb will not dim. The motion bulb will not work under a glass cover, according to the brand.

Those are the details that save you a return. We sort the three by the job. Moods, parties and scenes go to the TJOY.

Holiday and Halloween color without any setup goes to the red bulb. Dark entries, closets and hallways go to the motion bulb.

Prices are low across the group, so the cost of a wrong guess is small. The real cost is the trip back to the store, and the fixture rules for each bulb are how you avoid it.

TJOY · Wi-Fi smart RGB A19 bulb

A color bulb that lives inside its own app

TJOY Wi-Fi RGB A19 Bulb 2 PackRecommended, with caveats4.3 (233 ratings) 100+ bought in past month$16.99Power Up on Amazon
TJOY Wi-Fi RGB A19 Bulb 2 Pack: product photo

Datasheet · from the TJOY page

Specifications from the product page
Power9 watts
ShapeA19
BaseE26
Voltage120 volts
Color temperature6500 Kelvin
ControlApp, Voice
ConnectionBluetooth, Wi-Fi
Count4
In the boxBulb included, User Manual
MaterialPlastic

Works with / fits

Base: E26

Shape: A19

Voice assistants: Alexa, Google Assistant, Google Home

From the TJOY product page

The TJOY is an A19 bulb with an E26 base, rated at 9 watts and 800 lumens, with a 60 watt equivalent. The product page claims 16 million colors and tunable white from 2700K warm to 6500K cool. It ships as a two pack, with a 270 degree beam angle and a color rendering index of 90 on the spec sheet.

Control runs over Bluetooth and Wi-Fi through TJOY's Daybetter app. TJOY says Alexa and Google Assistant both work with it and that no hub is needed. It also says the bulbs support only 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi, not 5 GHz, and run only on 120 volt AC.

The brand is blunt about what the bulb leaves out. It says the bulbs do not support Tuya, Smartlife, Apple Home, Matter or SmartThings, and that they are generally not compatible with traditional dimmer switches. If your home runs on HomeKit or Matter, this is the point to look elsewhere.

Inside the app, TJOY lists preset scenes for Christmas, Halloween, dates, parties and reading. It also lists timers, such as an off time at sunrise or an on time at 7 p.m., and group control for several bulbs at once. Music sync listens through your phone microphone, so the phone has to stay nearby with microphone permission granted.

The product page lists FCC and UL under specifications met, plus a one year warranty and a rated life of 25,000 hours. It marks the bulb for indoor use only. Those are the brand's figures, and the build and fit are only as good as the unit that arrives.

Buyer reviews for this two pack are short and mostly about the basics. One buyer replaced burned out bulbs and found these brighter and whiter than the originals, and called the value excellent. Another says they look good in a light strand and have just the right brightness.

One reviewer mentions that the bulb sat too short to reach the socket contact, so check your fixture depth.

Ratings lean positive. The star average is 4.3 from 233 ratings.

Roughly one buyer in eleven gave a single star. Praise centers on brightness and value. The app-only setup is the brand's own description, so weigh it before you buy.

Best for a lamp or fixture where you want colors, scenes and voice control and already live in an Alexa or Google house. At $16.99 for the pair, the entry cost is modest. Skip it if you use dimmer switches, a 5 GHz-only network or HomeKit, and keep in mind that your lighting depends on one brand's app.

TJOY Smart LED Light Bulb · 0:44 · Video from the TJOY product page

What buyers wrote about the TJOY Wi-Fi RGB A19 Bulb 2 Pack

5 out of 5 Good replacement

I bought these to replace burned out originals. The bulbs work great, but are brighter and a more white light than the original bulbs. Excellent value!

Customer photo of the TJOY Wi-Fi RGB A19 Bulb 2 Pack
Customer photo via Amazon review (the United States, January 5, 2025)
Richard Helton · Reviewed in the United States on January 5, 2025 · Verified purchase · Amazon customer review, read November 16, 2026

GREENIC · colored A19 LED bulb (red)

Plain red light with no app and no dimming

GREENIC Red A19 LED Bulb 4 PackWe recommend4.6 (787 ratings) 100+ bought in past month$9.99Power Up on Amazon
GREENIC Red A19 LED Bulb 4 Pack: product photo

Datasheet · from the GREENIC page

Specifications from the product page
Power9 watts
ShapeA19
BaseE26 Medium
Voltage120 volts_of_alternating_current
ControlApp
ConnectionNormal bulb
Count4 Count
MaterialPlastic

Works with / fits

Base: E26

Shape: A19

From the GREENIC product page

GREENIC sells this as a four pack of red A19 LED bulbs. Each is 9 watts with a 60 watt equivalent, an E26 medium base and 120 volt AC power. GREENIC rates the life at 25,000 hours and says that works out to more than 11 years at six hours a day.

Each bulb measures 2.36 inches wide and 4.13 inches tall, according to the spec sheet.

The detail table marks the bulb as not dimmable, and a buyer confirms it with a shrug: not dimmable, but that's okay. There is no app, no Wi-Fi and no color change here. You screw it in, flip the switch and get red.

The real question with a red bulb is whether the red is red. A Canadian buyer who had tried other bulbs sold as red says they came out more orange when lit, and that the GREENIC bulbs are actually red. Another buyer calls the color vivid and bright.

A host who bought them for a Halloween party says the bulbs were a hit, with great color and a durable feel. The same reviewer says the bulb did not feel hot and screws in like any regular bulb. A Canadian buyer picked them up for Halloween ambiance and liked how they look.

The Greenic Red bulbs are actually red

Buyer review of the GREENIC Red A19 LED Bulb 4 Pack, Canada, December 23, 2025

A few reviews on this product come from buyers who bought the green version of the same bulb for Christmas accent lighting. They liked the color, and one said the green bulbs were hard to find in stores. Check the color you pick before you order, since this bulb is the red one.

The page also claims that a red bulb can help you sleep better in a bedroom. That is GREENIC's claim and not ours, and no buyer review in the group backs it up. We would pick this bulb for color, not for sleep.

The detail table marks the bulb for indoor use, even though the title mentions a porch. Check the manual before you put it in an outdoor fixture. Rated life and the 90 day guarantee are GREENIC's own terms.

The star average is 4.6 from 787 ratings, and only about one buyer in twenty rated it two stars or lower. Critical reviews are few, so the main risks are the ones in the spec table: no dimming, no color change and no app.

Best for Halloween, party and holiday color in a standard socket, at $9.99 for four. Skip it if you want dimming, a second color or any phone control. In that case the TJOY is the better match.

What buyers wrote about the GREENIC Red A19 LED Bulb 4 Pack

5 out of 5 Hits the spot.

Got some of these for our Halloween party and they were a hit. Great color, durable bulb. Didn’t feel like it was putting out much heat, and is a regular screw in bulb, so easy to swap in and out. Not dimmable, but that’s okay. It’s got great color production and was just what we were looking for.

Customer photo of the GREENIC Red A19 LED Bulb 4 Pack
Customer photo via Amazon review (the United States, July 21, 2026)
Customer photo of the GREENIC Red A19 LED Bulb 4 Pack
Customer photo via Amazon review (the United States, July 21, 2026)
Something Simple · Reviewed in the United States on July 21, 2026 · Verified purchase · Colour Name: Red · Amazon customer review, read November 16, 2026

GREENIC · motion sensor A19 LED bulb

A hallway bulb with a short memory

GREENIC Motion Sensor A19 Bulb 2 PackRecommended, with caveats4.3 (2,219 ratings) 1K+ bought in past month$9.99Power Up on Amazon
GREENIC Motion Sensor A19 Bulb 2 Pack: product photo

Datasheet · from the GREENIC page

Specifications from the product page
Power9 watts
ShapeA19
BaseE26 Medium
Voltage120 volts_of_alternating_current
Color temperature5000 Kelvin
ControlPush Button
ConnectionNormal Bulb
Count2
ModelA60 PIR MOTION BULB
In the boxmotion bulb
Weight3.84 ounces
MaterialPlastic

Works with / fits

Base: E26

Shape: A19

From the GREENIC product page

GREENIC's motion bulb is an A19 with an E26 medium base, rated at 9 watts and 800 lumens, with a 60 watt equivalent and 5000K daylight white. It comes as a two pack. The spec sheet shows a color rendering index of 85, a rated life of 25,000 hours and a one year warranty, and it marks the bulb for indoor and outdoor use.

The sensor sits at the top of the bulb. GREENIC gives a detection range of 10 to 13 feet and a detection height of 6.8 to 8 feet.

A photocell keeps the bulb off in daylight. GREENIC states about 18 lux as the on threshold and about 30 lux as the off threshold.

Once motion stops, GREENIC says the bulb switches off after 30 seconds. On first power-up it stays on and then goes off after about 30 seconds without motion. There is no setting for a longer or shorter time.

GREENIC gives a long set of install rules. Mount the bulb facing down or sideways, keep the sensor at the top uncovered, and do not use it in a glass or metal cover. Keep the wall switch energized, and don't pair the bulb with a touch, infrared, voice or light-control switch.

Buyers like it where it fits. One buyer uses it in the hallway from the garage and says it turns on as needed.

Another put it in a closet and says it triggers well and installs like any bulb. A Canadian buyer likes it at the front and back doors.

my only complaint is they don,t stay on long enough

Buyer review of the GREENIC Motion Sensor A19 Bulb 2 Pack, the United States, January 11, 2026

The most common complaint is how long it stays lit. Reviewers write that they would like the bulbs to stay on longer, and one says plainly: my only complaint is they don,t stay on long enough. Since the time is fixed, no setting will fix that.

Sensor coverage comes up too. One three-star reviewer says the sensor seems to work on one side only.

Another buyer put black tape over the sensor in a couple of locations to blind it and called that no problem. Both point at the same trait, a narrow field of view.

The fit warning is serious. One buyer returned the bulbs because it often is above 104° where they live, and because their porch housing is glass. They say the product insert, not the description, gave them those limits.

One 1-star review says both bulbs did not work.

The star average is 4.3 from 2,219 ratings, and roughly one buyer in twelve gave a single star. Best for a closet, a garage hallway or a bare-bulb doorway, at $9.99 for two. Skip it if your fixture has a glass cover or you want to set the on time.

What buyers wrote about the GREENIC Motion Sensor A19 Bulb 2 Pack

4 out of 5 Cannot use above 104° or through glass.

These really are sturdy light bulbs. They look like normal light bulbs so there isn't any give away they are motion sensored. I did have to return though, only because where I live, it often is above 104° many months of the year and the description only told me that on the actual insert. They also noted they won't work through glass, which my porch light housing is made of. Otherwise, in a bare bulb housing, and cooler outside temps, they may work for you.

BonJour · Reviewed in the United States on July 8, 2026 · Verified purchase · Amazon customer review, read November 16, 2026

3 out of 5 Just ok

The bulbs are at a good price, and they are quite bright, but the sensor only seems to work on one side, so if an intruder isn't on that side, they're pretty much useless--the bulbs that is. the other down side is the light doesn't stay on very long. Color is bright white which is a plus at night. They are easy to install just like a standard lightbulb.

Mimi · Reviewed in the United States on September 10, 2026 · Verified purchase · Amazon customer review, read November 16, 2026

1 out of 5 Doesn't work

Both bulbs are not working, im so disappointed

Premananth yogalingam · Reviewed in Canada on August 11, 2026 · Verified purchase · Amazon customer review, read November 16, 2026

How the three bulbs differ

SpecTJOY Wi-Fi RGB A19 Bulb 2 PackGREENIC Red A19 LED Bulb 4 PackGREENIC Motion Sensor A19 Bulb 2 PackAlso reviewed · TJOYTJOY CA11 E12 Candelabra LED 6-PackAlso reviewed · GREENICGREENIC 15W Red PAR38, 2 Pack
Price$16.99$9.99$9.99$18.99$10.99
Rating4.3 of 54.6 of 54.3 of 54.7 of 54.5 of 5
Ratings2337872,219895516
Power9 watts9 watts9 watts5.5 watts15 watts
BaseE26E26 MediumE26 MediumE12E26
ShapeA19A19A19CA11PAR38
Voltage120 volts120 volts_of_alternating_current120 volts_of_alternating_current120 volts120 volts_of_alternating_current
ConnectionBluetooth, Wi-FiNormal bulbNormal BulbE12Normal bulb
Count41262
ControlApp, VoiceAppPush ButtonTouchApp
Best forlamps where you want scenes and voice control from Alexa or GoogleHalloween, party and holiday lighting in an ordinary screw-in socketa closet, a hallway from the garage or a bare-bulb entrychandelier arms and sconces with E12 sockets and several bulbsa red porch or party fixture that takes a PAR38 bulb

The shape and wattage match, so the differences are in control and in what the bulb is allowed to touch. The TJOY gives you color and scenes but ties you to an app and to 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi.

The red bulb gives you one color and nothing else. The motion bulb gives you white light on demand and nothing else.

On brightness, the TJOY and the motion bulb share an 800 lumen rating. For the red bulb, judge brightness by buyers, who call it vivid and bright. Use it for accent light.

On fixtures, all three take an E26 base, but their rules differ. The TJOY avoids traditional dimmer switches. The red bulb is not dimmable.

The motion bulb wants an open fixture, a switch that stays on and no touch or voice switch in the circuit.

On setup effort, the red bulb is the simplest, since it is just a bulb. The motion bulb is nearly as simple but has the most install rules. The TJOY asks the most of you, with an app, a Wi-Fi band and an account of what your voice assistant supports.

If you want one answer for a living room, take the TJOY. For a holiday porch or party, take the red. For a dark entry that you pass through with full hands, take the motion bulb.

When another kind of bulb is better

A plain white bulb is better when you only want light. The TJOY 6 pack of 2700K A19 bulbs is the everyday route, and it avoids every app and fixture rule of the three bulbs above.

A colored flood is better when the fixture is a recessed can or a wide spot. The GREENIC red PAR38 flood bulb is the red option in that shape, and it is the better fit where an A19 would sit too deep or too narrow.

For a bedroom at night, an amber bulb is better than any of these three if you want warm low light. The Vgogfly amber bulb is sold as blue-light blocking, and that is the brand's claim, not ours. It is a plain bulb with no app.

A motion bulb is worse than a sensor built into the fixture when you need to set the on time or cover a wide arc. A buyer complained about exactly that, and the brand gives a fixed 30 seconds. A fixture or add-on sensor with a timer is better in a busy entry.

A smart bulb is worse than a smart switch when you run HomeKit or Matter, since TJOY says the bulb works with neither. In that case the switch route keeps the house on your system, and a plain bulb sits behind it.

What buyers say

TJOY Wi-Fi RGB A19 Bulb 2 Pack

4.3 (233 ratings) 100+ bought in past month
5 star73%
4 star8%
3 star8%
2 star2%
1 star9%

GREENIC Red A19 LED Bulb 4 Pack

4.6 (787 ratings) 100+ bought in past month
5 star84%
4 star7%
3 star4%
2 star3%
1 star2%

GREENIC Motion Sensor A19 Bulb 2 Pack

4.3 (2,219 ratings) 1K+ bought in past month
5 star69%
4 star13%
3 star6%
2 star4%
1 star8%

Brightness and value come up most. Buyers of all three bulbs use words like bright, vivid and good price. Nobody in the reviews we read complains that the red is dim, and the TJOY and the motion bulb both get credit for strong light.

Color accuracy matters most for the red bulb. A Canadian buyer says other red bulbs came out orange, and this one did not. That is the one claim that decides whether a red bulb is worth buying, and the reviews support it.

On-time and field of view dominate the motion bulb complaints. Several reviewers want the light to stay on longer, one wants a setting for it, and one says the sensor works on one side only. Two reviewers fixed or lived with it, one by taping over the sensor.

Failure reports are scattered. One buyer says both motion bulbs did not work. One says a short base kept a TJOY from reaching the socket contact.

The 1-star share is about one in eleven for the TJOY, one in twelve for the motion bulb and just a few percent for the red bulb.

For the smart bulb, comments focus on brightness and value, not on pairing. The weak spots in the brand's own notes are the app-only setup and the missing platforms. Read those before you order.

it often is above 104° many months of the year

Buyer review of the GREENIC Motion Sensor A19 Bulb 2 Pack, the United States, July 8, 2026

Do not support Tuya/Smartlife/Apple Home(HomeKit)/Matter/SmartThings

TJOY product page

Ratings, star breakdowns and “bought in past month” figures were read on the product pages on November 16, 2026.

How to set up the TJOY smart bulb

TJOY says the bulb must connect through the Daybetter app first, and that it works only on 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi. That makes the order of steps matter more than usual. Do the checks before you start, because a bulb in a dimmer socket or on a 5 GHz band will not connect.

The motion bulb has its own short setup. GREENIC says to mount it facing down or sideways, keep the sensor uncovered and leave the switch on. The first time it gets power, it stays lit and then turns off after about 30 seconds without motion.

If something does not work, look at the brand's own notes first. For the TJOY, that means the Wi-Fi band, the dimmer and the platform list. For the motion bulb, that means the cover, the switch type and the temperature limit buyers mention.

  1. Check that the lamp or fixture takes an E26 base and is not on a dimmer switch.
  2. Make sure your phone is on a 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi network, not 5 GHz.
  3. Download the Daybetter app that TJOY names on the product page.
  4. Screw the bulb in and switch the power on.
  5. Connect the bulb in the Daybetter app before you try Alexa or Google Assistant.
  6. Allow microphone access in the app if you want music sync.

Which one we would pick

Recommended, with caveatsTJOY Wi-Fi RGB A19 Bulb 2 Pack

The color range is wide, but the bulb works only through the Daybetter app and leaves out HomeKit and Matter.

Power Up on Amazon

We recommendGREENIC Red A19 LED Bulb 4 Pack

It does one job, makes real red light in a regular socket, and buyers say the red is not orange.

Power Up on Amazon

Recommended, with caveatsGREENIC Motion Sensor A19 Bulb 2 Pack

It triggers well in the right fixture, but the on time is fixed and glass covers are ruled out by the brand.

Power Up on Amazon

We recommend the GREENIC red bulb for anyone who wants red light for a holiday or party. It has the fewest ways to go wrong, buyers say the red is true, and the downsides are the ones on the spec sheet. If you want dimming or a second color, we don't recommend it.

We rate the TJOY conditional. The color range and scenes are broad, and it works with Alexa and Google Assistant by TJOY's account.

But it runs only through the Daybetter app, only on 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi, and not with HomeKit or Matter. We don't recommend it if you already run one of those platforms or use dimmers.

We also rate the GREENIC motion bulb conditional. It does its job in a closet or hallway, and buyers confirm that it triggers and installs easily. We don't recommend it for a glass-covered porch fixture or for anyone who wants a longer on time, because the brand's 30 seconds is fixed.

None of the three earns a flat no, since the faults are known and stated. Match the bulb to the fixture and the job, and you get what you pay for.

If a fixture has a glass cover, skip the motion bulb. If a socket sits on a dimmer, pick a plain bulb. If your phone lives on a 5 GHz-only network, ask whether the TJOY is worth changing your router settings.

Questions buyers ask

Which is better for a hallway, the TJOY or the GREENIC motion bulb?

The GREENIC motion bulb is better for a hallway, since it lights on movement and turns off after about 30 seconds, by the brand's account. The TJOY is a color bulb that needs an app, and it has no motion sensor. Use the TJOY for scenes in a lamp, and the motion bulb for a dark hallway.

Is the GREENIC red bulb good for Halloween?

Yes, the GREENIC red bulb suits Halloween, and buyers back that up. One Canadian reviewer bought it for Halloween ambiance and liked it, and a party host called the color great. It is a 9 watt A19 with an E26 base, and it is not dimmable, so plan on one brightness.

Does the TJOY smart bulb work with Apple HomeKit?

No. TJOY's product page says the bulb does not support Apple Home, Matter, Tuya, Smartlife or SmartThings. It works through the Daybetter app and with Alexa and Google Assistant. If your home runs on HomeKit, pick a different bulb, and use this one only if Alexa or Google is your system.

Can I use the TJOY bulb on a dimmer switch?

TJOY says the bulbs are generally not compatible with traditional dimmer switches. You set brightness through the Daybetter app, and the brand rates the maximum at 800 lumens. Leave a dimmer socket for another bulb, or turn the dimmer to full if the brand's notes allow it.

How long does the GREENIC motion sensor bulb stay on?

GREENIC says it switches off about 30 seconds after the last motion. Several buyers wish it stayed on longer, and one notes there is no way to set the on time. If you need a longer light, choose a fixture or sensor with an adjustable timer instead.

Can the motion sensor bulb go in a porch light with a glass cover?

GREENIC says not to use the bulb in a glass or metal cover, since the sensor at its top must stay clear. One buyer returned it because their porch housing was glass and local temperatures often topped 104°. Use it in a bare-bulb fixture or open housing.

Same circuit

More bulbs and nearby reviews

All LED & Smart Bulbs
TJOY Wi-Fi RGB A19 Bulb 2 Pack$16.99Power Up on Amazon