Review 012 · Heaters, Fireplaces & Heated Gear

Wall-Mount Electric Fireplace or Cast Iron Stove for a Cold Room

One fireplace hangs on the wall and one stands on legs, and the right pick depends on your floor space, your wall and the size of the room.

  • Published November 16, 2026
  • 13 min read
  • 2 products
  • Electactic

At a glance

Which electric fireplace fits a cold room

It is a cold evening in November, and the living room is the one room the furnace never warms enough. You want a glow in the corner and some heat on your feet, without hauling in logs or calling a mason.

The two fireplaces here solve that in opposite ways. The Electactic 36-inch insert is a flat panel that mounts on a wall or sits in a recess. The Electactic cast iron stove stands on its own legs and looks like a small wood stove.

Both top out at 1500 watts, and the brand gives 5100 BTU for each. Both also have a gentler setting, 750 watts on the insert and 500 watts on the stove. The stove adds a flame-only mode, so you can run the glow with the heat off.

The real split is where you have room. The insert needs a wall, and Electactic rates it for 400 square feet. The stove needs a patch of floor and an outlet, and the brand rates it for 1,000 square feet.

One buyer says the stove is plenty for a bedroom but only a secondary heat source in a large open room.

Every heater needs space around it. The U.S. Fire Administration says to keep anything that can burn at least 3 feet from all heat sources, including fireplaces, wood stoves, radiators, space heaters or candles.

That clearance decides where either of these can go, so measure your wall or corner before you pick one.

I lean toward the insert if you are planning a feature wall, and toward the stove if you rent or want to move the fireplace from room to room. Each has a catch, and you will meet it faster if you know it now.

Electactic · 36-inch recessed electric fireplace insert

A flat panel for the wall you can spare

Electactic 36-Inch Electric Fireplace InsertWe recommend4.5 (334 ratings)$129.98Power Up on Amazon
Electactic 36-Inch Electric Fireplace Insert: product photo

Datasheet · from the Electactic page

Specifications from the product page
MaterialMetal, Tempered Glass
In the boxLog, Remote Control
ModelElectric Fireplace
Size3.86"D x 36"W x 18.11"H
Weight28.7 pounds

Works with / fits

Room size (brand): up to 400 sq ft

From the Electactic product page

Electactic builds this one as a slab. It is 36 inches wide, 18.11 inches tall and 3.86 inches deep, and it weighs 28.7 pounds. The front is tempered glass in a metal body with a polished finish, and the brand says the bezel is nearly invisible so the flame fills the whole face.

The product page calls it a recessed and wall-mounted unit, and the spec sheet lists wall mount as the installation type. The power source is corded, so plan the path of the cord before you plan the frame. The manual covers mounting, and you should read it before you cut anything.

Heat comes from an infrared element at 750 or 1500 watts. Electactic gives 5100 BTU and a coverage rating of 400 square feet, and the product title lists a thermostat.

A timer runs from 1 to 8 hours. You run it with a remote or a touchscreen panel, and the brand says having both means a lost remote won't leave you stuck.

The flame is the part you will look at most. Electactic lists 12 flame colors and 12 bed colors, with adjustable brightness and speed.

One reviewer was confused at first and saw only different tints of yellow, then found two color buttons, one for the rocks and one for the flame. The same reviewer said the effect looks better in person than in the product video.

Sound is the brand's claim: 45 dB, with a sleep mode, plus built-in overheat protection. Those are Electactic's statements, and none of the reviews mention noise either way.

Buyers are happy with this one. It has 334 ratings averaging 4.5, and about 81 percent of them are five stars.

One reviewer set it on a chest on the floor instead of mounting it, found it bigger than expected and called the heat strong. Another dropped it into a camper in place of the old fireplace, with minor changes to the bracing inside.

Assembly tripped up the first reviewer. The manual said to remove one screw to free the glass plate, they took out all of them, and only then found slots in each corner that let the plate lift out. Read that step twice before you start pulling screws.

Who should skip it? Anyone who wants a stand-alone look with no wall or recess, anyone heating more than the 400 square feet Electactic rates, and anyone who expects a classic yellow flame without playing with the color buttons.

Resting it on a chest worked for one buyer, but the brand sells it for a wall, and the 3-foot rule from the U.S. Fire Administration still applies to whatever sits near it.

If you have the wall, it is the cleaner choice.

It sits close to the surface, it has two ways to control it, and it is rated for bedrooms and living rooms. We recommend it for a room of normal size with an outlet within reach of the cord.

Electactic Electric Fireplace · 0:26 · Video from the Electactic product page

What buyers wrote about the Electactic 36-Inch Electric Fireplace Insert

5 out of 5 Very satisfied

I'm so Happy with this Fireplace ! Its bigger than I expected ...I didnt measure my space..but its ok ..I can just sit it on top of my chest thats on the floor. .. i may mount it later..its good for now.. It says to remove 1 screw on the left side to remove the glass plate... I ended up removing g them all. Just to find out it has slots on each corner inside so it raises up to come out. Its my first electric fireplace ...and im not the best at these things..but I got it to do what I needed so its ok. ... All the functions work. I dont see it changing colors... but it shows different tints of light. Since I love the yellow flame. Thats fine with me. Or maybe I haven't figured something out on it yet... I will keep working on it. Re.ote works good heat works really good. I love the 2 choices of 750 and 1500w.. its beautiful ...gives warm and cozy ambience ... would…

Customer photo of the Electactic 36-Inch Electric Fireplace Insert
Customer photo via Amazon review (the United States, December 12, 2025)
Sky watcher · Reviewed in the United States on December 12, 2025 · Verified purchase · Colour Name: Black · Amazon customer review, read November 16, 2026

Electactic · freestanding electric fireplace stove

A small stove that needs floor space and some air

Electactic Cast Iron Electric Stove HeaterRecommended, with caveats4.3 (1,138 ratings)$181.48Power Up on Amazon
Electactic Cast Iron Electric Stove Heater: product photo

Datasheet · from the Electactic page

Specifications from the product page
MaterialCast Iron
In the boxLog, Remote Control
ModelS230B
Size10.7"D x 23.5"W x 24.3"H

Works with / fits

Room size (brand): up to 1,000 sq ft

From the Electactic product page

This stove is the opposite of a slab. The body is cast iron in a brushed grey finish, and it measures 23.5 inches long, 10.7 inches deep and 24.3 inches tall with the pedestal. Electactic says it weighs 33.18 pounds and that one adult can move it.

You attach the legs with screws, and the spec sheet lists a double door front.

Heat comes from a quartz element at 500 or 1500 watts, with 5100 BTU as the brand's figure. Electactic claims the 1500 watt setting heats a room up to 1,000 square feet in 10 minutes.

That is a bold claim, and buyers describe something smaller. One says it works as a primary heat source in a smaller confined space like a bedroom, but in a larger open area it is best used as a secondary heat provider.

Another reviewer reports that the stove warmed a 250 square foot room by 7 degrees in under an hour. That is one buyer's number, in one room, and it fits the bedroom story better than the 1,000 square foot rating.

Air flow matters here. The brand says the air outlet is on top, to avoid the hazard of bottom vents overheating carpets or floors.

One buyer adds that the unit draws air at the back panel, and that some people who complained it doesn't warm the room had it pushed against the wall. That buyer left 1.5 to 2 inches behind it and says it works great.

Another reviewer mentions warnings that the top gets hot while it runs.

We made sure to place it 1.5-2 inches away from the wall and it works great!

Buyer review of the Electactic Cast Iron Electric Stove Heater, the United States, October 16, 2025

The flame is a 3D effect on a curved LED screen, with five brightness levels.

The brand's numbers differ on color. One bullet says 16 color combinations, the spec lines say 4 flame and log colors, and the reviewer who counted found four choices, a bright red, a brownish orange and two mixes with blue. That reviewer gave four stars and was unhappy that none of them is a natural yellow.

Control is a remote or a touch panel, and you can pick flame only, heat only or both.

Reviews on the remote split. One says it works great without opening the doors. Another, who otherwise likes the stove, says it doesn't work very well.

Electactic also lists a tip-over shutoff and a timer that shuts the unit off, and it gives 37 dB as the sound level, all as the brand's claims.

Buyers rate it 4.3 across 1,138 ratings, with about 71 percent at five stars and about 7 percent at one star. Reviewers praise the metal build. One says the weight should make it hard for cats to knock over, which is a buyer's comment and not a safety promise.

The warranty is one year, per the spec sheet. Reviewers of the metal build call it durable and sturdy, and the stove ships with a log. Skip this stove if flame color matters a lot to you, if your room is big and open, or if the only spot you have is flat against a wall.

Electactic freestanding electric fireplace stove experience · 3:02 · Video from the Electactic product page

What buyers wrote about the Electactic Cast Iron Electric Stove Heater

5 out of 5 Love this neat fireplace

We really love it! We got this fireplace in grey. All as expected. This unit is fully metallic. Very sturdy. I like different colors and shades of flames and coal. I have read a review where it says that this unit draws air at the back panel snd not from the bottom and this is why some people complained that it doesn't warm up the room. We made sure to place it 1.5-2 inches away from the wall and it works great! This fireplace warmed up 250 Sq ft room 7 degrees under one hour. It has warnings about unit getting hot on top during operation, but we have not used it so long that it became an issue. This fireplace has multiple settings for the temperature and speed - you will.have to find what works for you.

Customer photo of the Electactic Cast Iron Electric Stove Heater
Customer photo via Amazon review (the United States, October 16, 2025)
NatDrm · Reviewed in the United States on October 16, 2025 · Verified purchase · Amazon customer review, read November 16, 2026

4 out of 5 Great quality! Wierd color flame NO YELLOW AS SHOWN IN photo

Would have loved to give it a five star review. It’s got a metal case that is wonderful in every way but one. THE FLAME COLORS ARE WIERD!!!! Brown and blue, unnatural! There are four flame choices. Yes there is a bright red (too solid) , and a kind of brownish orange, but no yellow. Then there are two, two color mixes with blue…why!. Yes blue is a flame color in scientific applications or propaine, but this fireplace is supposed to mimic a real wood fire. So, four choices, none of them very good. Sad.

Customer photo of the Electactic Cast Iron Electric Stove Heater
Customer photo via Amazon review (the United States, October 1, 2026)
Customer photo of the Electactic Cast Iron Electric Stove Heater
Customer photo via Amazon review (the United States, October 1, 2026)
Cheri · Reviewed in the United States on October 1, 2026 · Verified purchase · Amazon customer review, read November 16, 2026

5 out of 5 Better than expected

I am totally impressed by this heater. Better quality, looks and operation than I was prepared for. The size was perfect for where I wanted to place it, not too big, not too small. It throws out enough heat for a smaller confined area, like a bedroom as a primary heat source. If it's in a larger open area like I have it in it's best used as a secondary heat provider. It definitely helps take the chill out and adds a soothing warm comfort. All metal construction, durable, reasonably priced and great looks that serves a purpose is what I was looking for and this was it. Some complain about the top getting hot, not so in my book; it gets warm only towards the center of the top but not even warm to hurt a toddler if touched, I know this for a fact. The remote works great even without having to open the doors. I recommend this unit without hesitation.

NOLA · Reviewed in the United States on January 23, 2025 · Verified purchase · Amazon customer review, read November 16, 2026

4 out of 5 Nice looking

It is very heavy so it will be difficult for my cats to knock over. I love all the different levels of ambiance you can use. The remote doesn't work very well

Lisa M Copeland · Reviewed in the United States on November 20, 2025 · Verified purchase · Amazon customer review, read November 16, 2026

Insert or stove: where the two differ

SpecElectactic 36-Inch Electric Fireplace InsertElectactic Cast Iron Electric Stove HeaterAlso reviewed · SHINICShinic 1500W Ceramic Desk HeaterAlso reviewed · ElectacticElectactic 1500W Remote Digital Heater
Price$129.98$181.48$22.99$49.43
Rating4.5 of 54.3 of 54.4 of 54.3 of 5
Ratings3341,13897582
Size3.86"D x 36"W x 18.11"H10.7"D x 23.5"W x 24.3"H5.5"D x 6.3"W x 9.3"H6.22"D x 6.22"W x 8.7"H
Count1111
Best fora bedroom or living room wall with an outlet nearbya bedroom or small room where you want a movable fireplacewarming one person at a desk or a small bedrooma bedroom where you want to set it from the bed

The first difference is mounting. The insert goes on a wall or into a recess, and the stove stands on the floor.

If you have a free wall and want a built-in look, the insert fits. If you rent, or you want to carry the fireplace to another room, the stove is the one.

The second is room size. Electactic rates the insert for 400 square feet and the stove for 1,000.

Buyer reports run lower than the brand's higher figure: one reviewer calls the stove a primary heater for a bedroom and a secondary heater in a large open room. Treat 400 square feet as the sensible ceiling for either.

Power steps differ. The insert runs at 750 or 1500 watts, and the stove at 500 or 1500. Both give 5100 BTU, so at the top setting the heat is the same on paper.

The stove has a flame-only mode, which the brand describes as flame without heat.

Controls differ too. The insert has a remote and a touchscreen, and a 1 to 8 hour timer.

The stove has a remote and a touch panel, three modes, and an auto shutoff timer. The brand lists 45 dB for the insert and 37 dB for the stove, and each figure is the brand's own.

Flame is where buyers push back on the stove. The insert lists 12 flame colors and 12 bed colors, and one reviewer needed time to find the settings.

The stove has four colors by the spec sheet and a reviewer calls them unnatural. Weight is close: 28.7 pounds for the insert and 33.18 pounds for the stove.

Price and rating are shown next to the text: $129.98 and 4.5 for the insert, $181.48 and 4.3 for the stove.

When another kind of heater makes more sense

A plain space heater is better when you only want warmth. A ceramic model such as the 1500W ceramic heater is a single box you can move to whichever room you are in, and it doesn't need a wall or a stand. You give up the flame, and with it the reason many people buy a fireplace.

An infrared cabinet heater is better when you want a wood-cabinet look with heat aimed at the room. The oscillating quartz cabinet heater is one example. It suits a person who wants radiant warmth and furniture styling, and it asks for floor space like the stove does.

A garage or ceiling heater is better for a workshop. The two-pack ceiling-mounted heaters are made for that job, and a decorative flame is wasted in a garage.

For one person on one couch, a heated wrap such as the wearable heated blanket is the cheaper way to stay warm and heats a body, not a room.

A real wood stove is better when you want actual fire and have a chimney, but it brings logs, smoke and cleanup. Electactic says its stove has none of that.

Whatever you pick, the U.S. Fire Administration says never to use an oven to heat your home.

The National Fire Protection Association says heating equipment is one of the leading causes of home fire deaths. Nearly half of heating equipment fires (46 percent), it says, happen from December through February. That is a good reason to choose the heater that fits your space instead of the one that looks best in a photo.

What buyers say about both

Electactic 36-Inch Electric Fireplace Insert

4.5 (334 ratings)
5 star81%
4 star8%
3 star3%
2 star2%
1 star6%

Electactic Cast Iron Electric Stove Heater

4.3 (1,138 ratings)
5 star71%
4 star13%
3 star6%
2 star3%
1 star7%

The insert has 334 ratings and the stove has 1,138. About 81 percent of the insert's ratings are five stars and about 6 percent are one star. For the stove, about 71 percent are five stars and about 7 percent are one star.

Heat is the first theme. Reviewers of both say it warms a small space well.

One insert buyer says the heat works well and likes the two power choices. A stove buyer says it takes the chill out and is good for a bedroom.

Placement is the second theme. The stove reviewer who left a gap behind the unit says it solved a complaint they had read about, and the insert buyer who set the panel on a chest found it larger than expected. Measure first.

Flame color is the third, and the biggest complaint. The stove's four flame choices disappoint one reviewer, who wanted yellow and got red, orange and blue mixes. An insert buyer needed time to find the color buttons.

The remote is the fourth. Stove buyers disagree about it, and insert reviewers call the remote fine. Critical buyer reviews are few for both, so the star histograms carry more weight than any one story.

Build gets praise. The stove is called fully metal and sturdy, and the insert is described as a good fit for a camper replacement.

If it's in a larger open area like I have it in it's best used as a secondary heat provider.

Buyer review of the Electactic Cast Iron Electric Stove Heater, the United States, January 23, 2025

four choices, none of them very good

Buyer review of the Electactic Cast Iron Electric Stove Heater, the United States, October 1, 2026

Ratings, star breakdowns and “bought in past month” figures were read on the product pages on November 16, 2026.

How to set up and run an electric fireplace

Start with the spot. Pick a wall for the insert or a floor patch for the stove, with an outlet close enough for the cord. Mark where the unit will sit before you move anything.

Next, clear the space. The U.S. Fire Administration says to keep anything that can burn at least 3 feet from all heat sources, including fireplaces, wood stoves, radiators, space heaters or candles.

Curtains, rugs, couches and bedding all count.

Follow the manual for assembly. On the stove, the legs attach with screws. On the insert, the manual covers mounting and the glass plate, and one reviewer lost time on that plate, so read the step before you unscrew anything.

When the stove is in place, leave a gap behind it. One reviewer kept it 1.5 to 2 inches off the wall after reading that it draws air at the back, and reports it warms the room well. Check the manual for Electactic's own spacing.

Then choose the mode. The stove runs flame only, heat only or both. The insert runs at 750 or 1500 watts, and both have a timer.

Use the lower power setting when you only want to take the edge off.

Finally, shut it off when you leave. The U.S. Fire Administration and the National Fire Protection Association both say to turn space heaters off when leaving the room or going to bed.

  1. Choose a spot with an outlet close enough for the cord.
  2. Clear everything that can burn to at least 3 feet around the unit.
  3. Assemble the unit as the manual shows, attaching the stove legs with screws.
  4. Leave a small gap behind the stove, as one buyer did, and check the manual.
  5. Pick the power setting and set the timer.
  6. Turn the heater off when you leave the room or go to bed.

Which one we would pick

We recommendElectactic 36-Inch Electric Fireplace Insert

Slim, easy to run with two controls, and rated by buyers at 81 percent five stars, as long as you have a wall for it.

Power Up on Amazon

Recommended, with caveatsElectactic Cast Iron Electric Stove Heater

Sturdy metal build and good bedroom heat, but the flame colors disappoint some buyers and the remote gets mixed reports.

Power Up on Amazon

We recommend the Electactic 36-inch insert for a bedroom or living room where you have a wall, an outlet and a room under about 400 square feet. It has the higher share of five-star ratings, two ways to control it and a slim frame. The catch is that you commit a wall to it, and the camper reviewer needed some bracing.

We don't recommend it if you rent and cannot mount anything, or if you want to move the fireplace between rooms. Then the stove makes more sense.

The Electactic cast iron stove gets a conditional from us. It has a sturdy metal build, three modes and good reports for a bedroom. But buyers are split on the remote, one reviewer found the flame colors unnatural, and the 1,000 square foot claim doesn't match what a buyer reports in a large open room.

We don't recommend the stove if a natural yellow flame matters to you, if the room is large and open, or if you need it pushed flat against a wall. Buy it for a bedroom or small den, leave a gap behind it, and expect a flame that looks more like a lamp than a log fire.

Whichever you choose, follow the clearance and shut-off advice from the fire agencies, and read the manual before you plug it in.

Questions buyers ask

Which is better for a bedroom, the Electactic insert or the stove?

The Electactic 36-inch insert is better if you have a wall for it, and the cast iron stove is better if you need a movable unit. Both give 5100 BTU as the brand's figure, and a stove buyer calls it a good primary heat source for a bedroom. The insert is rated for 400 square feet.

Is the Electactic stove good for heating a large room?

It is better in a bedroom than in a large room. Electactic rates the stove for 1,000 square feet, but one buyer says it works as a primary heater in a smaller confined area and as a secondary heat source in a larger open one. Another says it warmed a 250 square foot room by 7 degrees in an hour.

Can the Electactic insert sit on a chest instead of the wall?

One buyer did exactly that, setting the 36-inch insert on a chest on the floor and thinking about mounting it later. The brand sells it as a recessed and wall-mounted unit, so check the manual for what it allows. The 3-foot clearance from anything that can burn still applies, per the U.S. Fire Administration.

How far should an electric fireplace stand from the wall?

The U.S. Fire Administration says to keep anything that can burn at least 3 feet from all heat sources. For the stove, one buyer left 1.5 to 2 inches behind the back panel because the unit draws air there. Electactic's manual has the spacing it wants, so read it before you place the stove.

Should I leave an electric fireplace on overnight?

The U.S. Fire Administration and the National Fire Protection Association both say to turn space heaters off when you leave the room or go to bed. Both Electactic fireplaces list timers, so you can set one and still turn the heater off yourself before you sleep.

Why is the Electactic stove flame brown and blue?

The stove has four flame and log color choices according to the spec lines, though one bullet mentions 16 combinations. A reviewer who counted found a bright red, a brownish orange and two mixes with blue, and no yellow. If a natural yellow flame matters, look at the insert's 12 flame colors instead.

Sources

This review touches on electrical, fire or indoor-air safety. It is general information, not professional advice: follow the product's manual, and ask a licensed electrician or HVAC technician about wiring, circuits and installation.

Same circuit

More heat and nearby reviews

All Heaters, Fireplaces & Heated Gear
Electactic 36-Inch Electric Fireplace Insert$129.98Power Up on Amazon